Search This Blog

Saturday, March 4, 2017

$1.6 BILLION 2017 Bonding Bill. Legislators Say They Refuse to Cut Any Pork. Call to Action.


Part I: List of Tens of Millions in Pork in 2017 Bonding Bill


3/11/17: Completely out of touch response from Senator Ingebrigtsen "Down with the Orange line. I get it." 

---------------------------------------
Here's my testimony for March 7th hearing. This is the fourth testimony I've made asking to cut only the wasteful spending. The author of the bill Senator Senjem kindly explained his perspective and refusal to cut one cent of spending; which, to me, flies in the face of common sense and why we elected them to legislate responsibly:
----------------
Dear Legislators,


we've been in an informative email exchange with Senator Senjem who we thank for answering some questions about his 2017 $1.6 BILLION dollar bonding bill SF210. From previous testimony you are likely aware of the lengthy list of ridiculous projects that are being funded in this bill (some listed below).  List of Tens of Millions in Pork in 2017 Bonding Bill

Senator Senjem responded: "I appreciate your perspective.  There are projects in this bill that wish were not part of it."

we responded: Great than please use your legislative power in committee and take these terrible project you agree are bad out! If not, can you explain why you can't say in committee: the voters elected us to cut spending... so we're going to take out pork barrel spending in SF210:
-the nightmare transit lines (orange line); 
-cut the spending to build TV stations, walking paths, pedestrian bridges, a garden at the zoo, and dentist office, etc. 
-funding of hundreds of millions to for profit colleges with massive sports franchises and refuse to lower tuition 
-spending for highly localized projects the State should have no business funding. 

Of highest concern is funding for the Met Council and funding to start new transit corridors like the Orange Line and build a ridiculous $8.7 million dollar train stop at the Mall of America. This is outrageous when we know the failure that these white elephants are costing State tax payer billions collectively. We have four transit corridors built already and none of them take more than 1% of traffic off the highway they parallel. Plus the Orange line is being built just north of the Red Line with the same failed mode of transit of BRT. The Red Line is the corridor with the WORST PERFORMANCE IN THE COUNTRY as I can find, with just 6% of operating cost being paid for by the riders according to the MNDOT Guideways Status Report!

Senator Senjem Responded: 
"If I take out one project out of it, and especially the one you cite [the orange line], the whole bill falls apart and we have nothing. I understand that some Rs want nothing because it is good personal politics.  As chair I have institutional responsibilities towards the good and welfare of our state's infrastructure and it would be totally irresponsible for me to let our state's infrastructure go without repair."  

Lastly, I responded:
1.) No one is asking that everything be removed.
2.) I'm not a politician, I work in medicine, so I have no personal political gain other than to escape oppressive taxes because of reckless spending
3.) Taking pork out of the $1.6 billion dollar bill would make it MORE popular not less wouldn't it? Especially with the GOP majority who was elected by voters like myself who thought this spending could stop. 
4.) I agree with you that your bill has dozens of much needed road projects and other infrastructure spending; however, I deeply disagree that a bill with hundreds of millions in waste should be passed because half of it has good projects.

If you could answer about why taking Pork out or even one $12 million dollar Orange line, would make it "fall apart" when there's a GOP majority in the House and Senate I'd appreciate it.

Thanks again so much for your time and your service to see the passage of a responsible bonding bill. I'd hate for a repeat of the 2011 session when the GOP controlled the House and Senate and DID NOTHING about Met Council and funded many transit projects including money for the Gold Line and the Red Rock Corridor. Ironically that was the last year (GOP control) that these two corridors got direct funding from the MNLeg. The following year the DFL took over the house AND senate because the GOP let the public down on wasteful spending:(

we find it shocking that when the GOP is in power they fail to act on their political promises and lose the following election because of it. However, it sounds like this is not so easily done. I await your explanation before jumping to conclusions.

Representative Senjem never responded. 
Representative Matt Dean responded with a great constitutional idea:
"Our constitution demands extra votes than a simple majority to borrow money.  I think we should do this for omnibus spending bills as well." (referring to SF210)

Conclusion:
Legislators, please do what we elected you to office to do. Stop making excuses and do your job and stop the wasteful spending you promised you were going to defeat. Saying you are just one legislator or worry that the Governor won't sign the bill are terrible myths. Because rolls reversed, the democrats always immediately roll out bonding budgets that are double this bill initially. They know ridiculous will never pass, but they offer it knowing they will cut it down to what they actually wanted (plain irresponsible). Afterwards, like a child with a 14th place trophy, Republicans leave the table honestly thinking they won. But in actuality they just got schooled.

We elected you to exercise the same winning strategy back on them... Slash the hell out of this bill... if Dayton Complains than listen to what few things he wants to get him to sign it and put a couple projects back and say that's the best you can do. But please for the love of the 2018 election do not put the Orange Line back in!



GOP Senate Passes $5.8 Billion Transportation Bill with $180 Million to Met Council & Mass Transit a Huge Raise


Friday, March 3, 2017

Stillwater ISD834 Spends Nearly $250,000 per class, Only 1/3 Goes to Teachers.

By: DeeDee Armstrong

Stillwater School District ISD 834 enrolls roughly 8,300 students. 
In the 2015-2016 school year the revenue was $106 million dollars (p.21 of the budget pdf), 
In the 2015-2016 school year the average student to teacher ratio was 18.99(p.146 of the CAFR pdf) 
That's a per pupil cost of $12,771 a year. Multiply that by the current average student to teacher ratio of 18.99 you get: 

Stillwater Area Public Schools spends 
                  $242,522 
per avg class of 18.99 students...PER YEAR!
(this is assuming every teacher has their own class, which is not the case. Some teach special ed, some classes have two teachers like in early education. So this number is very conservative)

Given that 85% of the budget is spent on staffing, a classroom of 18.99 (based on $242,522), shows the staffing is $206,143 per classroom per year. Looking back at data, we see that Stillwater teachers are earning around $70,000 annually, plus benefits, so lets call it $80,000.  That leaves $126,143 for other staff... like school psychologists, secretaries... And Central Services. 

$80,000 of $242,522 on teachers is ONLY $33% of the money going towards classroom teachers. That's only 1/3 of the budget going towards the teachers in the classrooms.

Lastly, we budget $529,017 for Travel and Conferences this year in ISD834. In 2015-15 we spent $302,857. Which is a 74% INCREASE since 2014-15.

Compare that to 622 (North St Paul - Maplewood- Oakdale). They enroll 10,660 students (larger than 834). 
This year they budget $390,441 for Travel and Conferences. In 2014-15, they spent $403,587. They DECREASED that line when their enrollment decreased.

Perhaps part of the problem in Stillwater School District is a spending problem.

Thursday, March 2, 2017

Five Years Later Union Depot's Quarter Billion Dollar Renovation Still Fails to Deliver Half the Riders Promised.

Article by Bill Hosko on the Union Depot. The location where the Gateway Corridor/Gold Line and Red Rock Corridor plans to end. Click the links to read more.
------------------
After St. Paul Mayor Chris Coleman, with others, oversaw a quarter billion renovation of Union Depot in 2012, they promised 2,600 riders a day to be using the hub once opened. Considering the 2,600 figure calculated by pro-transit www.streets.mn, from Met Council data, was an average of weekend and weekday ridership the figure could be rounded to 3,000 riders per weekday figuring ridership is less than 30% better on weekdays (it's much higher). The streets.mn article stated "of course, weekday service will be greater and weekend less."

Mayor Coleman and transit planners predicted merchants would clamor to fill the 95,000 square feet of open space and businesses would compete to fill the retail spots within. Fast forward to 2017 and you'll find the place is a ghost town and the coffee shop is struggling to stay open. A single cart offering cartoon illustrations for sale is the current centerpiece of this “transportation hub”, which is losing millions of dollars annually.  

According to Met Council's most recent data the Union depot hosts only 1,500 "boardings" a week day. That's half the riders promised now 5 years since the project was finished. What's worse is if you break down the numbers to show how many riders board per stop: 
1.) The Union Depot has service 24 hours a day. The Green Line stops at the Union Depot every ten minutes and at night stops once an hour from 1am to 5am during the week.
2.) According to Metro Transit's website the Green Line makes a stop at the Union Depot 114 times in a 24 hour weekday. 
3.) This equates to only 14 riders boarding at Union Depot on average per stop at the station.

If you view the entire Union Depot site, and all its levels, you should be left with the impression that a lack of commonsense planning ruled the day.  Things are so bad financially, funerals are held in the concourse through the doors to the center- left.  Amtrak is not happy. Greyhound bus pulled out of the deal before it even opened.  Will Amtrak be forced to find a way to move to north downtown Minneapolis?


This photo was taken Tuesday, 2-21-17 at 6 PM in Union Depot.  
In conclusion, Mayor Coleman is determined to prop up his largely failed legacy and his gubernatorial candidacy. He needs your help currently to do it.  I am a Saint Paul native and a long-time downtown business owner and artist.  


Bill Hosko
Saint Paul, MN 

Tuesday, February 28, 2017

License Plates for Pedophiles gains support



    

Bill Parker from www.minnesotansforabetterminnesota.org

wrote Legislators last month with much enthusiastic support. Washington County Watchdog 100% supports this bill idea. Representative Kathy Lohmer and others are reviewing the bill idea. This is from what he wrote:


We are currently encouraging our Legislature here in Minnesota and encouraging all Minnesotans to contact their respective Legislators and insist that Pedophiles classified as Level 3 Predatory Offenders (Considered most likely to reoffend) are required to display a "Pedophile Plate" on their vehicles just as our repeat DUI offenders must display that "Whiskey Plate" on their vehicles. Per the Department of Justice website "child molesters were more likely than any other type of offender to be arrested for a sex a crime against a child. Many other reoffend by failing to register their address with Law Enforcement, possession of child pornography, invasion of privacy, stalking, trespassing, burglary or other precursor crimes as they hunt for children not in their notification area.
Here is an example where Pedophile Plates would have made a difference.
 AARON CARL GILBERTSON
Tried lure victims into a car (female, age 6) & offered money to victims (age 11 and 13) for sex acts. & Indecent Exposure. The State of Minnesota vs Aaron Carl Gilbertson: Case No. 62-K7-98-002147 & CASE No. 62-K9-97-600908
 
Nine out of ten Minnesotans we speak with are in favor of such legislation. The very few opponents to such legislation usually object because of one of the following reasons;
(1) Invasion of Privacy: This was overcome and a precedent set by the "Whiskey Plate" legislation which addressed the balance of privacy of repeat D.U.I. offenders against public awareness and public safety.
(2) Vigilantism: Unlike other sex offender license plate legislation that has been proposed here in Minnesota, Alabama, Ohio and Wisconsin it would only apply to Level 3 offenders (classified as most likely to reoffend by the Department of Corrections and ALREADY SUBJECT TO PUBLIC NOTIFICATION) that have been convicted of or civilly committed for a sex crime against a minor. Also full enforcement of existing hate crime laws will deter people from vigilantism. 
(3) Cost to taxpayers: The cost would be carried by the offender also a donation to a non-profit victims fund. Similar to specialty plates in Minnesota that require a minimum $30 donation to the DNR, Veterans groups, Etc..
(4) Statistics reflect that most children are molested by a friend or family member: While it is true that most pedophiles start with children they know. However this changes after they are caught a time or two. They quickly realize that the grooming and threats wear off as the children age and they will continue to get caught unless they change their tactics. Once they change their tactics and start victimizing children not in their notification area and unknown to them they are rarely if ever caught. This skews the statistics because they are based only on sexual predators that are caught and convicted.
Minnesota ranks as one of the worst states in dealing with sexploitation of our children, this must change. We feel that this legislation would make Minnesota a safer place to raise our children.
Will you fight for our children and sponsor this Bill idea?

Sincerely,
Bill Parker

Monday, January 23, 2017

Red Rock Corridor Plan Falls Apart Now Wants to be Called Route 363

Update 5-2018: South Washington County's Red Rock Corridor "Terminated"!



The Red Rock Corridor. A 30 mile Bus Rapid Transit (BRT) corridor from Hastings to St. Paul Faces Delays as 7 Facts Become Undeniable, as one of our original articles state. In the article you see the corridor's planning history filled with evidence of attempts to manipulate the public's understanding of the corridor. Whether it's being deceptive on the cost of the corridor, to approving a plan to double the number of station stops in attempt to get ridership numbers to build on paper. This last ploy, was titled the "implementation plan" it cost tax payers $550,000 and apparently it's being thrown out the window for the latest change.

The newest plan ditches the 12 stop corridor plan and even the original 6 stop plan in favor of turning the Red Rock Corridor into a local bus route. Millions have been invested in planning and re-planning this "Bus Rapid Transit" corridor to try to make the plan work to gain coveted federal funding. But no matter how they twisted the numbers they weren't even close to the feds who'd like ridership over 2,000 riders a day. So now the new plan is to re-brand and look under any rock they can for funds to keep the corpse of this terrible corridor idea moving forward. (read on to see why it's so bad) The BRT plan is now a "long term" design for the year 2040!

At the  September 2016 Corridor Commission meeting they explain since they can't get the Red Rock Corridor built they should get funding for a bus route they can later rename the Red Rock Corridor: 
"The proposed Route 363 is a local bus route acting as a precursor to BRT implementation in this corridor."

Route 363:
By doing this the corridor, if you can call it that anymore, can apply for funding from all new sources that have no idea how bad the corridor idea is. The plan was set and they applied  to the Met Council for $5.9 million to go towards building the $7.8 million dollar route. On the application it is called Route 363 which is a bus route will run with existing express bus routes 361, 364, and 365 that currently serve the Cottage Grove area. This new Route is planning to have 1,200 riders a day and is a ridiculous prediction as route 361, 364, and 365 have a combined ridership of just 475 riders a day!  (sourced here under number 5 from Metro Transit's latest study)

Read more about Route 363 on the Metro Transit's Service Improvement Plan (SIP) just hit "ctrl + f" on the key board and search "363." It was such a bad idea that Metro Transit even passed up investing in it last year. 

Funding denied From Met Council:
On January 18th the Met Council denied the funding request for the route according to Elaine Koutsoukos head of the Met Council's TAB (Transportation Advisory Board). It serves an embarrassing failure to the Corridor planners who were hoping to pull off pushing the Red Rock Corridor forward in butchered down form. It marks the second denial from the Met Council to invest in the corridor after they were denied funding to build low income housing by the Newport Transit Station. You know a transit corridor is a terrible idea when the Met Council turns you down time and time again.

Newport Transit Station will hurt Route 363:
The least popular of the three routes is route 364 which has the longest ride time since it stops at the Newport Transit Station which is isolated and has no direct connection to the Highway. This evidenced in the ridership which is a dismal 37 rides a day or just 18 riders a day (same Metro Transit source as above). Route 363 will incorporate the unpopular Newport Transit Station. 

Ridership predictions we can't trust:
In the October 2016 Corridor Commission meeting they claim 1,200 riders a day will be using route 363. This ridership prediction is ridiculous as it's Two and a half times the combined amount of our 3 current express bus routes as stated earlier. We know ridership predictions from corridor planners are extremely off. In 2012, the year before the Red Line Corridor was built just 20 miles south, they predicted 2,250 riders a day OVER the express bus ridership... turns out they were 1,400 riders a day short! The Northstar corridor predicted there'd be 9,500 riders a day by 2020 in the current Big Lake to Minneapolis layout in 2006 (p.27); but only has 2,500 riders on this design today (p.16)... They were off by 7,000 riders a day! 

But they're going to run all day service and have more buses they say. 
Surely if we simply send enough buses back and forth from relatively rural South Washington County all day long the ridership will multiply two and a half times.... False! We can say this with certainty because for 3 years the Red Line has been staring us in the face with the evidence of only 835 riders a day.

The Red Line in Apple Valley as evidence:
We know route 363 will fail because this experiment has already been tried with the Red Line Corridor. Finished in 2013 the corridor has just 835 riders a day according the latest 2015 MNDOT Guideways status report. This is Solid evidence because the population there is three times more dense, serving a road with twice even the 2030 volume of hwy 61 for route 363, and they have more concentrated shopping centers and housing down there. (sourced here under number 4)

$5.5 million a year to operate:
Worst of all the operating costs for Route 363 will be higher than the Red Line Corridor. Local tax payers will be on the hook to cover the $5.5 million a year to operate the bus line burning diesel. Not to mention the wear and tear on the local streets caused by the heavy buses. How much damage? Take the example of just one dump truck to operate in Washington County in our state they have to pay over $4,000 a year to city, state, and counties to cover road damage.

How bad is this Route 363 that will become the Red Rock Corridor? Here's all Seven massive reasons the corridor will be a failure and the evidence to prove it is sourced (I only shared two of seven):

How do we know the Corridor will be so terrible? How about the fact none of the 40 planners can answer just One question:
Over 40 Red Rock Corridor Decision Makers Unable to Provide Answers About New Route